A search firm RFP is a written request that asks executive search firms to propose how they would run a specific leadership search, who would run it, on what timeline and at what cost. A strong one has five parts: a defined role, a list of required firm information, stated deliverables, a commercial terms section and scoring criteria set before proposals arrive. This guide covers each part and the process around it, using published U.S. RFPs as worked examples.
TL;DR
- Use an RFP when a search is high-level, confidential or restricted in its candidate pool, and when several firms could credibly handle it.
- Ask for the firm overview, comparable searches, references, the named team, methodology, timeline and itemized fees.
- Define the role, success criteria, deliverables and milestones in the RFP so every firm prices the same work.
- Check responsiveness first, then score with weighted criteria fixed in advance, using more than one evaluator.
- Treat published fee and scoring figures as examples to adapt, not market standards.
Table of Contents
- When an RFP is the right way to hire a search firm
- What to ask firms to include
- Defining the role, scope and deliverables
- Fees and commercial terms to request
- The RFP process, step by step
- Scoring proposals consistently
- Conflicts and confidentiality
- Perspective: what in-house talent leaders can add
- Support for corporate teams running searches
- FAQ
- Sources
When an RFP is the right way to hire a search firm
Not every executive hire needs a formal bid process. An RFP fits when the role is senior, the candidate audience is narrow, or the cost and risk justify comparing several firms. Washington State University's search firm guide notes that an external firm can help with high-level roles or positions with a restricted applicant audience, such as dean, vice president and chancellor searches.
In a corporate setting, the same logic applies to roles such as a Chief People Officer, Chief Talent Officer, head of talent acquisition or head of executive recruiting. Three conditions usually point toward an RFP:
- The search is confidential, and the firm must handle a sitting leader's replacement or a sensitive reorganization.
- The company expects to run several searches with the same firm, so the relationship has lasting value.
- Procurement, legal or finance requires a documented selection with comparable bids.
For a single, urgent search with a known shortlist of firms, a shorter request for proposal or a structured interview process may do the same job. The RFP is a tool for comparability and defensibility.
What to ask firms to include
The RFP should make every firm answer the same questions in the same order. Published examples show a consistent core.
A 2026 CEO-search RFP from BNEDC requested a firm overview, comparable searches, at least three references, work samples, methodology, a timeline, assigned-team biographies and roles, and detailed pricing, including fees and reimbursable expenses. That list works as a base outline for a corporate RFP.
Firm and team information
Ask about the people, not only the brand. WSU's guide asks for the background and qualifications of the firm members involved, including the team leader, and the number, type and status of ongoing searches. The last item shows how much capacity the lead adviser has for your search.
The Association of Executive Search and Leadership Consultants (AESC) makes the same point in its guide to choosing a search firm. It describes executive search as a consulting engagement and advises clients to assess the individual adviser and the quality of advice, not only fee levels. It also recommends making the lead adviser accountable in the written agreement.
Experience and references
Require comparable search experience and references. The Metropolitan Pier and Exposition Authority (MPEA) RFP requests vendor qualifications that include comparable search experience and references, along with the firm's approach to a nationwide search and to attracting diverse talent.
For a corporate talent team, "comparable" should be defined in the RFP itself: the function (HR, talent, recruiting), the seniority, the industry and the company size. Ask for a minimum number of references and permission to contact them.
Methodology and candidate reach
Ask firms to explain how they find candidates. MPEA's RFP asks firms to describe targeted sourcing strategies, network reach and use of industry databases while seeking a diverse candidate pool. AESC's selection guidance adds assessment and reference-check processes, communication cadence, conflicts and confidentiality to the list of areas to evaluate.
Fit with your organization
WSU's guidance says a firm should understand the organization's needs, culture, environment and structure and take a consultative approach. An RFP can test this directly by including a short case question: "Based on the attached role summary, what are the three biggest risks to this search and how would you address them?"
Defining the role, scope and deliverables
Firms can only price and plan what the RFP describes. Vague scope produces proposals that cannot be compared.
The role and success criteria
MassArt's 2026 RFP calls for position analysis to clarify role scope, reporting relationships and success criteria, and for drafting or refining a comprehensive position profile. A corporate RFP can include a draft profile and ask the firm to say what it would change.
AESC advises that clients brief the search team, identify what must be kept confidential, agree the timeline and milestones, and have relevant parties sign off on the search strategy and position specification. Settle internal sign-off before the RFP goes out, so that the finalist firm is not working against an unresolved brief.
Deliverables to require
The City of Richmond's specification lists candidate profiles, a shortlist, interview support, finalist evaluation, references and background checks, and offer-negotiation assistance as deliverables. Listing them in the RFP lets you see which firm includes which step and avoids surprises in the contract.
MassArt's RFP also illustrates an end-to-end model in which position definition, proactive sourcing, structured assessment, due diligence, negotiation, onboarding, reporting and a replacement commitment are treated as one integrated service. Ask each firm to state which of these are in the base fee and which are not.
Timeline and milestones
MPEA asks for a realistic search schedule with milestones such as sourcing completion, candidate presentation and interview stages. Request the schedule in weeks from engagement, and ask what the firm needs from your team at each step, such as interview availability and feedback turnaround.

Fees and commercial terms to request
Ask for pricing in a fixed format so bids line up. BNEDC's RFP asked for detailed pricing that separates fees from reimbursable expenses. A fee table in the RFP should cover:
- The fee structure and how it is calculated.
- Any minimum fee.
- The invoicing schedule.
- Out-of-pocket expenses and how they are capped or approved.
- What happens if the search is paused, cancelled or restarted.
- The replacement commitment, if a placed executive leaves.
As one example of what a contract can contain, a University of Tennessee executive search agreement sets a 30% fee on first-year total cash compensation with a $65,000 minimum, billed in three equal invoices at the start of the search and at 30 and 60 days. It identifies direct out-of-pocket expenses separately. This is one contract's terms, not a universal market rate, and your RFP should let firms state their own structures.
AESC cautions against comparing fee levels alone. Fees belong in the evaluation, but they are one criterion among several.
The RFP process, step by step
- Prepare the brief. Draft the position profile, confidentiality requirements and internal approvers.
- Publish a timetable. The 2026 BNEDC RFP set dates for questions, answers, proposals, evaluation and interviews, and selection, covering roughly three weeks from the question deadline to selection. A short, fixed timetable keeps the process fair and fast.
- Open a question period. Answer questions in writing and share the answers with all invited firms.
- Check responsiveness. Covered California's executive-recruitment RFP used a pass/fail first phase for required administrative content, then scored only responsive proposals in a second phase.
- Score and interview. Workforce Solutions Capital Area scored responsive proposals with a standardized instrument and could invite selected proposers to interview or join a question-and-answer session.
- Negotiate and contract. The Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) negotiates scope of work, schedule, terms and conditions, technical specifications and price with the selected firm, and may turn to another proposer if talks fail.
Public-sector processes are more formal than most corporate ones. Corporate teams can keep the structure and drop the procurement language.
Scoring proposals consistently

Scoring criteria belong in the RFP, so firms know what the company values and evaluators work from one standard. MPEA's process first reviews proposals for responsiveness and administrative compliance, then has an evaluation committee assess them using the same stated criteria. The committee may request clarifications, presentations or meetings. Its criteria cover methodology and approach, sourcing and diversity, communication and transparency, relevant experience, team qualifications, references, and fees and value.
Two published weightings show how different organizations balance quality and cost:
| Criterion | Covered California | WFS Capital Area |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding and approach | 20% | 20 points |
| Corporate qualifications / experience | 20% | 40 points |
| Project-team qualifications | 20% | Included in experience |
| Past projects | 10% | Included in experience |
| Cost | 30% | 40 points |
| Total | 100% | 100 points, 70-point threshold |
The Covered California weights come from its RFP 2025-16. The WFS figures come from its executive search RFP and are adaptable examples, not corporate standards. The WFS "included in experience" cells reflect that its scoring has three categories, not five.
Practical rules for a corporate scorecard:
- Fix the criteria and weights before proposals are opened.
- Use at least two or three evaluators, and have each score independently before a group discussion.
- Write a one-line justification for every score.
- Do not select on lowest price alone. Cost is one weighted criterion.
- Keep final approval and contract negotiation with a named executive.
Covered California's example shows that defensibility comes from separating responsiveness screening from weighted technical and cost scoring, using multiple evaluators and documenting recommendations.
Conflicts and confidentiality
Ask every firm about conflicts. AESC advises clients to raise potential conflicts when selecting a firm, and explains that off-limits agreements may apply to placed candidates or to people on the team affected by a search. For an in-house recruiting leader this matters most when the company has several open searches or recently placed executives with the same firm.
Add to the RFP:
- A disclosure of current clients in the same industry whose searches could overlap.
- The firm's off-limits policy and its duration.
- How candidate and client information is handled and who on the firm's side can see it.
- Your own confidentiality requirements, such as limits on naming the company in outreach until a candidate is qualified.
Perspective: what in-house talent leaders can add
Running a search firm RFP is a benchmarking exercise. The questions that matter are the ones other in-house leaders have already asked: how many searches the lead adviser is carrying, how fees were structured, what the firm did when a search stalled, and how candidates were treated.
In nearly three decades of operation, we have seen that corporate recruiting leaders get better answers from peers who have no commercial interest in the outcome. Our communities are exclusive to in-house leaders and are vendor-free, so members can compare notes on firm selection, fee structures and results in a confidential setting.
We also see the RFP as one input. Reference calls with peers who have used a firm, and a clear internal scorecard, support the formal process. Teams that build both tend to document their decisions more clearly and reuse the work for later searches.
Simon
Support for corporate teams running searches
IX Communities runs peer networking and benchmarking groups for in-house leaders. The ESIX membership is built for corporate executive recruiting leaders. TLIX serves talent leaders, and DSIX serves diversity strategy leaders. Membership pricing is not published.

The ExecSmart database and talent acquisition books are also available. The database is a proprietary resource on search consultants. Recruiter training through IX Academy starts at $350 for on-demand courses, $750 for live online courses and $3,000 for team intact courses.
FAQ
What should a search firm RFP include?
Include a role summary, the information required from each firm, deliverables, a timeline, a fee format and the scoring criteria. Required firm information typically covers the overview, comparable searches, at least three references, work samples, methodology, assigned team and pricing, as in the 2026 BNEDC RFP.
How long should an executive search RFP process take?
The BNEDC example ran about three weeks from the question deadline to selection, with proposals due in the middle of that window. Corporate timetables vary with the number of firms and approvers. Publish the dates in the RFP and keep them.
How should fees be compared across proposals?
Ask every firm to fill in the same fee table: percentage or fixed fee, minimum, invoicing schedule, expenses and replacement terms. Then compare totals for a sample compensation level. One published contract used a 30% fee with a $65,000 minimum, but that is an example, not a market rate.
What weight should price carry in scoring?
Published examples range from 30% at Covered California to 40 of 100 points at WFS Capital Area. Choose a weight that reflects your priorities, state it in the RFP and avoid selecting on lowest price alone.
Is an executive search RFP always necessary?
No. It suits senior, confidential or restricted-audience searches, repeat engagements and companies that need a documented selection. For one urgent search, a shorter process with a few interviews may be enough.
Sources
- Washington State University, Search Firm Guide (2024)
- MPEA, Executive Search Firm RFP (2025)
- BNEDC, RFP for Executive Search Firm (2026)
- AESC, Global Guide to Choosing an Executive Search Firm
- MassArt, RFP 26-10 Specifications and Description of Services (2026)
- City of Richmond, executive search project detail (2025)
- Covered California, RFP 2025-16: Executive Recruitment
- Workforce Solutions Capital Area, Executive Search RFP (2025)
- University of Tennessee, executive search contract
- OCPA, RFP Executive Recruitment Services (2023)
