Ethical HR benchmarking comes down to three commitments: share only what the law and your counsel allow, keep individual companies unidentifiable, and make every pay or hiring decision independently. For talent acquisition leaders, the practical way to meet all three is to benchmark inside a structure with written rules, a neutral steward and aggregated outputs, rather than through informal calls with competitors. Peer groups limited to in-house corporate leaders, with confidential and peer-sourced data, are built for that purpose. This article sets out the principles, the U.S. antitrust position, a code of conduct you can adopt and the confidentiality terms that belong in it.
TL;DR
- Benchmarking is lawful and useful. Exchanging competitively sensitive compensation or hiring terms with competitors is where the antitrust risk sits.
- The 2025 FTC/DOJ guidelines replaced the 2016 HR guidance and are read as stricter on information sharing, including through third parties and algorithms.
- A workable code of conduct covers source vetting, aggregation, data age, independent decisions, training and a ban on confirmatory contacts.
- Confidentiality terms protect the participants. They do not make an unlawful exchange lawful, so the content of the exchange still needs legal review.
- Run exchanges through a structure with written rules and legal sign-off, not through ad hoc conversations.
Table of Contents
- What benchmarking ethics means in HR
- The ethical principles behind employee data
- The U.S. antitrust rules that frame the exchange
- A code of conduct for benchmarking participants
- Confidentiality agreements in benchmarking
- Reducing the risk of identifying a company or person
- A step-by-step ethical benchmarking routine
- Why the setting of the exchange matters
- Where IX Communities fits
- FAQ
- Sources
What benchmarking ethics means in HR
HR benchmarking compares one HR function's performance and practices with another's. APQC describes four types: external (against industry peers or talent competitors), internal (across units or regions), quantitative (cost, cycle time, quality) and qualitative (interviews, case studies, open-ended surveys).
Ethics enters because the data describes people and pay. Three questions come up each time a team benchmarks:
- Is the exchange lawful? Competitors that share wage or hiring terms can create antitrust exposure.
- Is the data handled responsibly? Employee information has privacy, transparency and bias obligations.
- Is the result used honestly? Benchmarks inform a decision. They do not replace it, and they are not a way to align with competitors.
Talent acquisition leaders face this more than most HR roles. Recruiting teams compete for the same candidates, so the people you compare notes with are often the companies you hire against. That makes the structure of the exchange as important as the metrics in it.
The ethical principles behind employee data
Two professional sources give a clear framework for data about employees.
The HR Policy Association's AI Principles sort employee-data ethics into five categories:
- Privacy and security: data is not used for purposes incompatible with its collection without consent.
- Transparency: intended uses are explained clearly, including any algorithms.
- Integrity: intent is positive, and AI augments people rather than replacing them.
- Bias: results are monitored continuously and corrected for unintended bias.
- Accountability: trained, accountable individuals are responsible across the life of a system.
SHRM's resource on privacy and ethics in people analytics adds that employees give employers rights to a great deal of data, that it must stay private, that only people who need it for their jobs should access it, and that its use must comply with local laws and regulations.
For a benchmarking program, these translate into simple habits. Submit only what the benchmark needs. Strip out anything that identifies a person. Limit internal access. Explain to your own leadership what will be shared outside the company and in what form.
The U.S. antitrust rules that frame the exchange
The legal risk in HR benchmarking is not the comparison itself. It is an agreement or exchange between competing employers that affects pay, benefits or hiring.
What the 2016 guidance said
The FTC and DOJ's 2016 Antitrust Guidance for Human Resources Professionals states that agreements among competing employers to limit or fix wages, salaries, benefits, terms of employment or job opportunities may violate U.S. antitrust law. It told HR professionals to put safeguards in place to prevent inappropriate discussions with other firms hiring the same employees.
The guidance cites a DOJ case against the Utah Society for Healthcare Human Resources Administration. Hospitals exchanged nonpublic current and prospective wage information for registered nurses, matched wages and kept pay artificially low. The case ended in a consent judgment.
The same document explains when an exchange about employment terms may be lawful: a neutral third party manages it, the information is relatively old, it is aggregated to protect the identity of sources, and enough sources are aggregated that competitors cannot link data to one company.

What changed in 2025
On January 16, 2025, the agencies issued new Antitrust Guidelines for Business Activities Affecting Workers, which replaced the 2016 guidance. The same analysis notes that the DOJ withdrew its 1996 healthcare information-sharing policy statements in February 2023 and the FTC followed in July 2023. The 2025 Guidelines warn that exchanging competitively sensitive compensation data may violate antitrust law, including through third parties or algorithms. They also reach independent contractors and franchise no-poach agreements, and they reaffirm that wage-fixing and no-poach agreements can lead to criminal charges.
Pillsbury's review says the 2025 text takes a stricter stance on information sharing. It leaves out many of the 2016 risk-reducing safeguards and stresses potential liability even when an employer keeps discretion over its own pay decisions. It reads this as a sign of higher enforcement risk for wage benchmarking through third-party aggregators or algorithms.
The practical reading for a talent leader: the older safeguards remain sensible habits, but they are no longer a guarantee. Have counsel review any benchmark that touches compensation before your team contributes to it or relies on it.

Red flags to train your team on
The DOJ Antitrust Division's Red Flags for Employment Practices lists behavior that should prompt a call to legal:
- agreeing with another employer on salary ranges or benefits;
- agreeing not to solicit or hire each other's employees;
- exchanging company-specific compensation data;
- discussing any of these at trade-association meetings or social events.
The document warns that managers and HR professionals may face criminal or civil liability. It also invites anyone who notices suspicious behavior to report it to the DOJ Citizen Complaint Center (antitrust.complaints@usdoj.gov, 1-888-647-3258) or the FTC Bureau of Competition (antitrust@ftc.gov, 202-326-3300).
The last red flag matters for recruiting leaders. Peer events are valuable, but a conversation in the hallway about what each company pays recruiters or offers candidates is exactly the situation the agencies describe.
A code of conduct for benchmarking participants
A code of conduct turns principles into rules people can follow without a legal seminar. The American Bar Association's antitrust newsletter, Counseling the HR Department, recommends three policy elements. The Milbank client alert on recruitment and compensation compliance adds specifics on data age, group size and training. Combined, they give a code with seven parts.
| Code element | What it requires | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Source approval | Legal reviews and approves each benchmarking data source, vets the provider and confirms data is anonymized and historical | ABA |
| Independent decisions | The company sets its own rates, salaries and benefits and does not follow a third-party data set | ABA |
| No confirmatory contacts | Employees may not contact competitors to check or confirm a data point, especially companies hiring from the same talent pool | ABA |
| Neutral steward | A neutral third party manages sensitive compensation information instead of companies sharing it directly | Milbank |
| Historic data only | Share only historic information; at least three months old is typically safe | Milbank |
| Minimum group size | At least five participants so data can be aggregated and not tied to one company | Milbank |
| Aggregated output and training | Distribute only aggregated information; train staff on compensation and recruitment antitrust issues and repeat the training for new hires | Milbank |
Two additions make the code more useful in practice.
Map the other forums. Milbank recommends identifying where else sensitive compensation information might be exchanged, such as industry roundtables and trade associations. Your code should apply there too, not only to formal surveys.
Give people a stop rule. One sentence works: if a conversation turns to what a named company pays, offers or plans to pay, end it and tell legal. A rule that short gets used.
The three-month and five-participant figures come from a law firm's alert on the 2016 framework. Given the stricter 2025 reading, treat them as a floor and ask counsel whether your data warrants more.
Confidentiality agreements in benchmarking
Confidentiality terms protect participants from having their data exposed. They are a core part of a benchmarking group's rules. They have limits, which is worth stating plainly: an agreement to keep something secret does not make an unlawful exchange lawful. If the content is competitively sensitive pay data shared directly between competitors, secrecy does not cure it. The content, age, aggregation and steward come first, and the confidentiality terms sit on top.
A sound confidentiality framework for a benchmarking group usually addresses these points:
- Scope. What counts as confidential: submitted data, group discussions, reports and member lists.
- Permitted use. Benchmarks are used to evaluate and improve your own practices, and for no other purpose.
- Attribution. Members may not name another company as the source of a figure or statement outside the group.
- Access. Only the people who need the material for their jobs receive it, which tracks the SHRM point on access.
- Independent decisions. Each member confirms that it makes its own compensation and hiring decisions.
- Legal compliance. Participation follows the antitrust and privacy laws that apply, and members raise concerns with counsel.
- Duration. Obligations continue after membership ends.
Have your own counsel draft or approve the final language. The wording of an agreement should reflect your company, your jurisdiction and the data in question.
Reducing the risk of identifying a company or person
Identification risk is the most common practical failure. A table with five companies is not anonymous if one of them is the only firm of its size in a region. Several habits reduce the problem:
- Aggregate with enough contributors. The 2016 guidance and the Milbank alert both tie protection to enough sources that no competitor can link a figure to one company.
- Report ranges and medians, not outliers. A single high value invites guesswork about who supplied it.
- Use older data for sensitive items. Historic data is less useful to a competitor planning a current pay move.
- Keep individual-level detail out. Recruiter-level or candidate-level records seldom belong in a cross-company benchmark.
- Control for comparability, not identity. Paycor's benchmarking guide says the most common mistake is comparing metrics without adjusting for organization size, industry or geography. Group peers by those traits rather than by naming them.
When compensation data for candidates or recruiters involves location, remember that pay-history rules differ by state. This checklist on salary history bans versus pay transparency is a useful companion when your recruiters design offer processes that draw on benchmark data.
A step-by-step ethical benchmarking routine
Paycor outlines a seven-step process: identify the business problem, select metrics, gather clean internal data, source external benchmarks, analyze gaps, prioritize and implement changes, and monitor and re-benchmark on a set cadence. Add an ethics checkpoint at each step.
- Define the question. Write down what decision the benchmark informs. If the answer is "to match what a competitor pays," stop and speak with counsel.
- Select metrics. Prefer process and performance measures such as time to fill, recruiter workload, source mix and technology use. These are less sensitive than pay data.
- Prepare your own data. Remove personal identifiers and confirm you have the right to use the data for this purpose.
- Choose the source. Use the legal approval step from your code. Check who runs the exchange, who sees the raw data and how outputs are aggregated.
- Analyze gaps. Compare against peers that match your size, industry and geography.
- Decide independently. Record the business reasons for any change, so that the decision stands on your analysis and not on a third party's number.
- Re-benchmark and retrain. Repeat on a set schedule, and refresh antitrust training so new recruiters and hiring managers know the rules.
Why the setting of the exchange matters
The same data can carry different risk depending on who gathers it and who receives it. A neutral steward, aggregated outputs and written rules reduce the risk. A casual phone call to a competitor's recruiting head, or a vendor-run survey whose participants and sponsors you cannot see, adds to it.
Corporate recruiting leaders also have a second concern, which is commercial influence. When vendors sit in a peer group, members may moderate what they share. A group made up only of in-house leaders removes that pressure and keeps the conversation about practice, not sales.
Our perspective
We have run peer groups for corporate talent leaders for nearly three decades. In that time the most consistent request from members has been a place to compare notes on how recruiting functions are organized, measured and equipped, without worrying who else is in the room.
That is why we limit our communities to in-house corporate recruiting leaders and keep them separate from vendor influence. Our benchmarking is peer-sourced and confidential, and our communities are organized around the work: talent leadership in TLIX, executive search in ESIX and diversity strategy in DSIX.
Ethical benchmarking depends on structure more than good intentions. Written rules, a clear purpose and members who understand the antitrust and privacy limits make a group safer for everyone in it. We encourage every member to review how they use benchmark material with their own counsel.
Simon
Where IX Communities fits
Our membership communities give corporate talent leaders a confidential, vendor-free setting to benchmark and learn from peers. TLIX serves talent leaders, ESIX serves executive recruiting leaders and DSIX serves diversity strategy leaders. Membership prices are not published.
For teams that need to train recruiters on process and conduct, IX Academy courses are available on demand from $350, live online from $750, and as Team Intact courses from $3,000. Members can also draw on guest speaker sessions, guidebooks and the ExecSmart database through the membership page.

FAQ
Is HR benchmarking legal?
Yes. Comparing your HR metrics and practices with others is a standard practice. The risk comes from agreements or exchanges between competing employers on wages, benefits, terms of employment or hiring, which the FTC and DOJ say may violate antitrust law. Have counsel review any benchmark that includes compensation.
What should a benchmarking code of conduct include?
At minimum: legal approval of data sources, independent pay and hiring decisions, a ban on confirmatory contacts with competitors, aggregated and historic data, a minimum number of participants and recurring training. The table above lists each element and its source.
Does a confidentiality agreement make data sharing safe?
No. It protects participants from disclosure, but it does not change whether the exchange itself is lawful. Competitively sensitive pay data shared between competitors can still create antitrust exposure. Content, age, aggregation and a neutral steward matter first.
What should I do if a peer conversation turns to pay or no-poach terms?
End the discussion and tell your legal department. The DOJ's red-flags document lists salary agreements, no-poach agreements and company-specific compensation exchanges as warning signs. It also gives the DOJ and FTC contact details for reporting suspicious behavior.
Sources
- APQC: What Is HR Benchmarking?
- Paycor: What Is HR Benchmarking? A Guide for HR Leaders
- HR Policy Association: AI Principles
- SHRM: Privacy and Ethics in People Analytics
- FTC and DOJ: Antitrust Guidance for Human Resources Professionals (2016)
- WilmerHale: Antitrust Compliance: What to Know for 2025
- Pillsbury: New DOJ-FTC Antitrust Guidelines
- DOJ Antitrust Division: Antitrust Red Flags for Employment Practices
- American Bar Association: Counseling the HR Department, A Look at Benchmarking
- Milbank: Antitrust Compliance in Employee Recruitment and Compensation
- Salary History Bans vs Transparency: HR Checklist
